Baron's Cove

The hotel is beautiful from the restaurant, to the lobby, to the rooms. The grounds are beautiful. Love the soft bedding. Thanks for an enjoyable two night stay. We will come back next year. Looking forward to spending a few relaxing nights at Barons Cove soon.

Beautiful hotel, reception were so friendly and helpful. Food was fab - that seafood tower and the best Lobster roll I've ever had! Spicy Margaritas were also delish! Short drive from the ferry and short walk into the lovely town. Music in the bar in the evenings was great, and unexpected especially off season.

I have been at this property before (hotel and restaurant) and traditionally viewed it as a top-notch option for staying in Sag Harbor, however they are inflexible and unpleasant. I helped organize a high profile business retreat at the property and inadvertently booked a non-refundable rate well in advance. When our group's plans changed well in advance of the stay, Cape Resorts was unwilling to refund the amount (for the stay this upcoming October), provide me with a credit for a future stay, or enable me to use it toward food/beverage for our meeting. Travel and hospitality should include "hospitality". I will not recommend this property in the future because their management is lacking in empathy and humanity.

Just Wow! We have just spent 5 nights at Barons Cove and would recommend to anyone!. The location is stunning, right on the marina with lovely views to wake up to and a nice sun set as well. You are 3-4 mins from Sag Main Street but far enough away be a lovely calm environment. We stayed in a Loft suite and the room was stunning. Split level with lots of living space and a great balcony overlooking the pool. Nespresso machine with fresh pods each day. As an English couple the absence of a kettle was missed but we cheekily bought a kettle in town and with a fridge in the room could keep milk fresh! The Food is very good. Breakfast is a great selection and very flexible with what you can order and in what combination, the smoothies especially were excellent. We had dinner one night on the hotel balcony and the food matched the view, both are outstanding. Very pleasant bar and terrace for a drink pre or post dinner also. What sets the hotel apart though is the staff. They were so good I made a point of getting names to email the hotel directly to praise them. We had an issue on the first evening with the room which Maria on the front desk listened to, came and checked out and agreed we needed to move rooms. No fault of the hotel just an AC issue that couldn't be avoided. However the way Maria dealt with it was first class and she had us moved and settled in in no time. She then went out of her way to speak to her colleague Saeed ( on his night off bless him) to ensure we didn't need to move again later in the week despite all rooms being booked. I must also mention Saeed for his general help and recommendations and friendliness, Mohamed on the front desk for the same and his incredibly cheerful demeanour, Cassandra in the restaurant, Kitty for her impeccable drinks delivery and her softened Irish accent and Mr Kitty as he became known ( Adam) out at the pool. All of them raise the level of the stay to top class and I have to say with incredible patience having seen how other guests treat them. They are all wonderfully managed and looked after by Caroline as Concierge clearly has the patience of a saint. All in all a great hotel, staffed by wonderful people in a perfect location.

Like most places in the Hamptons, the restaurant at Baron's Cove is overpriced. The decor is meant to look "Olde Sag Harbour" and, it does. It's quite cozy. But, the service, particularly in the bar area has always been oddly slow ... to the point of being frustrating ... even when it isn't crowded.